I Belong to Both Worlds. Why Do I Feel Caught Between Them?

Written by Bethanie Milford, LCSW

Edited by Christina Thompson

I keep wondering why conversations between autistic people without intellectual disability and those who care for autistic people with intellectual disability can become so divided, especially when caregivers can be autistic themselves. What do we gain by deciding whose perspective belongs in the autism community? And what might we miss when we stop listening to one another?

Where I Stand Between These Worlds

I sit at this intersection as a neurodivergent clinician and the parent of an adult autistic daughter with intellectual disability. There have been stretches when I have had to sift through months of memories to find a day when my daughter seemed at ease and able to enjoy herself. That has varied over time, and there have been periods with many more good days. But some stretches brought deep grief. Keeping her safe and trying to get her the support she needed took so much of me that my own health and livelihood fell by the wayside.

When “Center Autistic Voices” Lands Like a Punch

That is part of why “center autistic voices” can feel like a punch in the gut when it is the response to something painful that I have shared. The more conversations I have had in caregiver spaces and in clinical spaces with autistic colleagues, the more I have seen how quickly people can put me in the “autism mom” box. With that label can come the assumption that I see my daughter as a burden or that I am making her experience my own. I can see how a story told from a parent’s perspective might raise that question. I would also ask how two people’s experiences could help but overlap when one is in distress and the other has been there with her day after day, trying to understand what she needs and get her help.

What We Lived Through as a Family

We lived through many of those moments together as a family, and each of us experienced them in our own way. I can speak directly about what I felt. When I talk about my daughter’s experience, I can share what she communicated, what we observed as a family, and what I am still unsure about. As the people who supported her day to day, we have learned to recognize how she shows distress, expresses a preference, or lets us know she has had enough. Why would we leave that knowledge out of a conversation about how to understand and support her?

I understand that autism and intellectual disability are distinct diagnoses. In my daughter’s daily life, both are present, even as her support needs change. I cannot always tell where one influence ends and the other begins when I am trying to understand how she communicates or responds to sensory experiences. Centering her means paying attention to all the ways she communicates, what brings her joy, and what helps her feel safe and understood.

When Autistic Voices and Caregiver Voices Overlap

Some clinicians have told me they had not been aware of things I had learned through these conversations. I can see how easy that is when people spend time in spaces that rarely overlap. Some autistic clinicians focus their work on people without intellectual disability, and I respect that. I also want us to remember that many caregivers of autistic people with intellectual disabilities are autistic themselves. Where do those of us who live both experiences fit when “autistic voices” and “caregiver voices” are treated as opposing groups?

What Comes Up for Me When People Celebrate Autism

Lately, I’ve been trying to understand how freeing an autism diagnosis can feel when it finally gives someone language for a lifetime of experiences. I can see why someone would want to celebrate their strengths or wear a “Neurospicy” T-shirt. And sometimes, hearing people talk about autistic “superpowers” takes me back to those months when it was hard to find a good day for my daughter. I’m trying to sit with that discomfort and examine my own assumptions, even when it feels like I’m swallowing the hardest parts of what our family lived through.

What We Celebrate Publicly and Talk About Privately

As a clinician, I’ve worked with autistic people without intellectual disability who have experienced severe depression, eating disorders, or addiction. In some neurodivergent-affirming clinical spaces, I’ve seen strengths like attention to detail celebrated openly while the frightening or painful experiences come up in private messages. I’ve seen that pattern across enough spaces that it’s hard to unsee. It makes me wonder what people learn about which parts of their lives they’re welcome to share.

Can We Disagree and Keep Listening?

What I struggle with most is when disagreement turns into a pile-on. I have often been the only person in a room who sees something differently. I am willing to listen and revisit my views. If I still see things differently after listening, I am willing to say so, even when the rest of the room agrees.

What would it look like to listen more closely to autistic people whose ways of communicating are often overlooked, and to take seriously what the people who support them every day have learned alongside them?

What We Were Trying to Tell People

Too often, when a parent puts those experiences into words, people hear a complaint about their child. What we were trying to describe was how scared and helpless we felt watching our daughter struggle while one provider or agency after another passed us along. After so many calls and referrals, we were hanging on by a thread, wondering if help would ever come and how we were supposed to get through another day while we waited.

Before a Family Reaches a Breaking Point

Today, what scares me even more about the divide in the autism community is that caregivers who are already gasping for air will give up on asking for help. When a family reaches a breaking point, their story may be called a tragedy. How often do we go back and ask how many times they reached out, who passed them along, and where the system failed them?

What We Owe Families as Clinicians

I’m also troubled by how easily dismissive responses get repeated in some clinical spaces, including by some autistic clinicians. As a neurodivergent clinician myself, I think we have an ethical responsibility to examine our own biases and consider the harm our words can cause. When we hear a caregiver’s fear as a complaint about their loved one, we can miss what they’re trying to tell us about the support that person needs and how long the family has been trying to get it.

 

Next
Next

When Challenging Views Gets Reframed as “Non-Affirming”